Comments on: Dil Jo Na Keh Saka http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html It's all about Mohd Rafi Mon, 12 May 2008 03:38:49 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.0.4 by: sanjaya srivastava http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-26509 Sat, 12 Apr 2008 04:17:44 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-26509 "Dil jo na kah saka wahi ...!". Emotionally chocked RAFI SAHAB's voice, really a moonlight in the throat. We are in tears as RAFI SAHAB is no more with us. "Teri Jami se uthenge to aasma honge, hamarae aise log jamane mei phir kahan honge." Long live Rafi Sahab!!!!! - Sanjaya Srivastava, IPS, Comandant, PAC Etawah. “Dil jo na kah saka wahi …!”. Emotionally chocked RAFI SAHAB’s voice, really a moonlight in the throat. We are in tears as RAFI SAHAB is no more with us. “Teri Jami se uthenge to aasma honge, hamarae aise log jamane mei phir kahan honge.” Long live Rafi Sahab!!!!! - Sanjaya Srivastava, IPS, Comandant, PAC Etawah.

]]> by: Raja http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-26451 Thu, 10 Apr 2008 18:59:14 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-26451 Thanks Chandni Ji, very nice article. It gave insight to Rafi Sahabs my most lovable songs. Its a very good idea that we discuss some of his excellent songs like this. I would love any one discuss Rafis song from April Fool A Gale Lag Ja, which I believe no other singer can dare try to sing. This song has special place in my heart because in my opinion this is one of the Rafis hardest songs to sing and the ease and emotions with which this genius has sung is simply amazing. Can someone please write more on this song/ Thanks Chandni Ji, very nice article. It gave insight to Rafi Sahabs my most lovable songs. Its a very good idea that we discuss some of his excellent songs like this. I would love any one discuss Rafis song from April Fool A Gale Lag Ja, which I believe no other singer can dare try to sing. This song has special place in my heart because in my opinion this is one of the Rafis hardest songs to sing and the ease and emotions with which this genius has sung is simply amazing. Can someone please write more on this song/

]]> by: Manish Kumar http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25740 Tue, 25 Mar 2008 18:49:35 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25740 Ms Chandni, Thanks so much for your most *excellent* article! I really enjoyed re-reading it after the greatness of the song finally sank in! I got addicted to this Rafi song last night and I'm been listening to it all day. Your points are spot on. Most importantly, you brought attention to a SUPREME song that I was sadly not earlier aware of. Thanks again! - Manish Ms Chandni,

Thanks so much for your most *excellent* article! I really enjoyed re-reading it after the greatness of the song finally sank in! I got addicted to this Rafi song last night and I’m been listening to it all day. Your points are spot on. Most importantly, you brought attention to a SUPREME song that I was sadly not earlier aware of. Thanks again!

- Manish

]]> by: kn.kumar http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25687 Mon, 24 Mar 2008 11:39:11 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25687 Thanks for a wonderful article on a wonderful song Chandniji. Keep writing on other songs so that we get an oppurtunity to discuss many things on the same. I agree that though Pradeep Kumar and Bharat Bhushan got many good songs to sing on screen of Rafi Saab, they were not able to bring the required emotions and feelings and people went to the theatres to only hear Rafi Saab. What a wonderful experience to hear the great soul in a big auditorium. It is really sad that the present generation is missing the great experience people of our generation was lucky to experience. Thanks for a wonderful article on a wonderful song Chandniji. Keep writing on other songs so that we get an oppurtunity to discuss many things on the same. I agree that though Pradeep Kumar and Bharat Bhushan got many good songs to sing on screen of Rafi Saab, they were not able to bring the required emotions and feelings and people went to the theatres to only hear Rafi Saab. What a wonderful experience to hear the great soul in a big auditorium. It is really sad that the present generation is missing the great experience people of our generation was lucky to experience.

]]> by: A S MURTY http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25639 Sat, 22 Mar 2008 15:31:14 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25639 ref post 34 by acharyashammi bhaskar sahab. sir, you have said it all for all of us in just one sentence - rafi was the god of songs. nothing more need to be said after this and this is one of the finest comments i've come across in recent times. short but to the point. keep it up. ref post 34 by acharyashammi bhaskar sahab. sir, you have said it all for all of us in just one sentence - rafi was the god of songs. nothing more need to be said after this and this is one of the finest comments i’ve come across in recent times. short but to the point. keep it up.

]]> by: rakesh chandra http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25605 Fri, 21 Mar 2008 17:50:18 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25605 MOHD. RAFI SAHAB WILL REMAIN IN OUR MEMORY FOR END LESS TIME WE ARE SPEACH LESS AND DONT HAVE WORDS TO SAY INTHE PRAISE OF GREAT LEAGEND MOHD RAFI. NO OTHER SIGER CAN TAKE HIS PLACE IN COMING TIME NEITHE R IN THE INDIAN MUSIC NOR WESTEN MUSIC WE SHOULD FEEL PROUD THAT PERSON LIKE MOHD RAFI BORN IN OUR COUNTRY MOHD. RAFI SAHAB WILL REMAIN IN OUR MEMORY FOR END LESS TIME WE ARE SPEACH LESS AND DONT HAVE WORDS TO SAY INTHE PRAISE OF GREAT LEAGEND MOHD RAFI. NO OTHER SIGER CAN TAKE HIS PLACE IN COMING TIME NEITHE R IN THE INDIAN MUSIC NOR WESTEN MUSIC WE SHOULD FEEL PROUD THAT PERSON LIKE MOHD RAFI BORN IN OUR COUNTRY

]]> by: Acharyashammi bhaskar http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25595 Fri, 21 Mar 2008 07:50:00 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-25595 UNBELIEVABLE VOICE QUALITY UNMATCHED EXTRAORDINARY WORDS FELL SHORT RAFI WAS GOD OF SONGS MR ACHARYA SHAMMI BHASKAR UNBELIEVABLE VOICE QUALITY UNMATCHED EXTRAORDINARY WORDS FELL SHORT

RAFI WAS GOD OF SONGS

MR ACHARYA SHAMMI BHASKAR

]]> by: Raju Korti http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-24732 Tue, 11 Mar 2008 15:58:30 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-24732 mr anoop my surname is korti and not kotri. anyway thanks for the response. also thanks to janab khaja aliuddinji who is right on target. but there are two more rafi songs in detective. one is the rib tickling "ankhon pe bharosa mat kar" (solo) and other a duet with geeta dutt "aaja kar le muquabila ye baazi hai pyarki". incidentally, the film had two other songs. one a geeta solo "do chamakti ankhome, kal khaab sunehra tha jitna" and other a duet with hemant kumar "mujhko tum jo mile, ye jahan mil gaya." the film was directed by shakti samant and lyrics by shailendra. the composer was one non descript mukul roy. the 1958 film starred pradeep kumar, mala sinha, dhumal, johny walker and k n singh. the heroine was not madhubala but mala sinha. i stand corrected. mr anoop
my surname is korti and not kotri. anyway thanks for the response. also thanks to janab khaja aliuddinji who is right on target. but there are two more rafi songs in detective. one is the rib tickling “ankhon pe bharosa mat kar” (solo) and other a duet with geeta dutt “aaja kar le muquabila ye baazi hai pyarki”. incidentally, the film had two other songs. one a geeta solo “do chamakti ankhome, kal khaab sunehra tha jitna” and other a duet with hemant kumar “mujhko tum jo mile, ye jahan mil gaya.”
the film was directed by shakti samant and lyrics by shailendra. the composer was one non descript mukul roy. the 1958 film starred pradeep kumar, mala sinha, dhumal, johny walker and k n singh.
the heroine was not madhubala but mala sinha. i stand corrected.

]]> by: P. Haldar http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-24724 Tue, 11 Mar 2008 14:14:36 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-24724 ref post 30: mukul roy was geeta dutt's brother. he scored music for only a few films. Here's a relatively well-known duet (Hemant-Geeta) from detective -- "mujhko tum jo mile ye jahan mil gaya": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMyTix1MRw0 ref post 30:

mukul roy was geeta dutt’s brother. he scored music for only a few films. Here’s a relatively well-known duet (Hemant-Geeta) from detective — “mujhko tum jo mile ye jahan mil gaya”:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMyTix1MRw0

]]> by: Anoop http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-24704 Tue, 11 Mar 2008 06:21:45 +0000 http://www.mohdrafi.com/video-songs/dil-jo-na-keh-saka.html#comment-24704 Namaste Raju Kotri Saheb I read your response in which you have stated that Late Hemant Kumar Ji told you that Rafi Saheb was suffering from cold while recording the song from Do Dil. This is one of my favourite song and was surprised to know that Rafi saheb could sing so well in these conditions as well. Will you please write about what Late Hemant Kumar Saheb had opinion about the singing talent of Rafi Saheb. Thanks & regards, Anoop. Namaste Raju Kotri Saheb

I read your response in which you have stated that Late Hemant Kumar Ji told you that Rafi Saheb was suffering from cold while recording the song from Do Dil. This is one of my favourite song and was surprised to know that Rafi saheb could sing so well in these conditions as well. Will you please write about what Late Hemant Kumar Saheb had opinion about the singing talent of Rafi Saheb.

Thanks & regards,
Anoop.

]]>