Comments on: Voh Bharat Desh Hai Mera

By: Imtiyaz A. Sharif

Imtiyaz A. Sharif — Wed, 23 Jul 2008 09:43:37 +0000

Ref. post 13, it’s already mentioned in the last para. “Sikandar-e-Azam”.

By: Dr. Khaja Aliuddin

Dr. Khaja Aliuddin — Wed, 23 Jul 2008 04:36:47 +0000

Dear esskay,
Salam,
Film is Sikander-e-Azam, MD Hansraj Behl and lyrics by Rajinder Krishan.
Abad Rafi,
With regards,
Dr. Khaja Aliuddin

By: esskay

esskay — Tue, 22 Jul 2008 15:44:54 +0000

plz let me know from which film is this song

By: Sohail Abbas

Sohail Abbas — Thu, 20 Dec 2007 19:21:11 +0000

hi
will somebody please tell me address of an online purchasers of lyrics
i want to sell my lyrics in bollywood

By: Sohail Abbas

Sohail Abbas — Wed, 19 Dec 2007 19:23:12 +0000

Dear friends,
I have been reading you comments on the ‘old saga’. I am also a fan of Rafi from Pakistan. There is no doubt that many singers have been ruling Bolly Wood. All of them can be called, atleast, the king of their time. We, being the music lover, should not call any singer a bad singer. This is a field where even a non- routine voice like that of Himaish Reshmia can rule the hearts.One thing that only rafi sahib had was extreme of soul in singing. This is what really matters to an ordinary listener like me. I would like to present my analsis as under:

Rafi Sahib is the end product of music ( the music which is called bread of soul)
Kishore Kumar is the Foundation of music of upcoming generations.
For me, immortality lies only in being end product or Foundation
Everything else can be called ‘Commercially Viable’ but not immortal

By: mohanflora

mohanflora — Wed, 23 Aug 2006 04:15:30 +0000

Hi venkat_brahma,
I have the song “nange bazoo nangi rane” on CD and can send you the same. Pl. send your e-mail.
Regards

By: vkchandiramani

vkchandiramani — Fri, 18 Aug 2006 10:21:42 +0000

Rafi shab was only one and the best of all Playback singers. From Sehgal to Sonu Nigam no one can even think to compair him self with Rafi Sahab. And pl pl pl no body should do that. becouse no body is even near rafi Sahab. In his voice the God was singing so who can claim a comparision with God……

Mukesh Kishore Manaday talat all male singers all are not more than and can not be more than 25% of Rafi Sahabs capability.

Mahender Kapoor is 50% of Rafi Sahabs Capability

Jahan Dal Dal per Sone ki chidiya

This is the best Petriotic songs of rafi sahab i thing all other songs are good This is some thing differant.

By: unknow1

unknow1 — Wed, 16 Aug 2006 12:22:58 +0000

Dear friends,
I don’t want to compare mohd rafi with any one but i want answer one thing that there was not Mohd Rafi time from 1969/70 to 1976?!!!!Dear friends Mohd Rafi singed in more than 160 films from 1969 to 1976!!!!but the problem was that Mohd rafi singed for poors MD and unknow actors(mostly),
Also I don’t to compare SJ or Naushand with LP and RD al lof them are great,
I want say about mohd Rafi voice that is a magic or God gift only for one human on this earth and that was Mohd Rafi.
I think the best singer is who can copy Mohd Rafi the best way.(as I think)

By: venkat_brahma

venkat_brahma — Wed, 16 Aug 2006 11:44:28 +0000

Folks,

Has anyone heard recently this number of Rafi saab: ‘Nange bazoo nangi rane’ from Yeh Zindagi Kitni Haseen Hain (1966)?

I happened to hear this yesterday on Rafi Jukebox after a number of years and got nostalgic. If anyone has this song with them, can they help transfer it to my collection? The unfortunate thing is that these rare numbers are just not available even with HMV (now SAREGAMA). Of course, a lot of them are now available only with AIR Vividhbharathi.

Regards,
Venkatadri

By: Pearl

Pearl — Wed, 16 Aug 2006 10:18:03 +0000

Let me tell you, I didn’t compare RD, LP with SDB, O.P. Nayar but at the same time, I know
that they are not too bad to say 100% mediocre. You asked Rafi, you asked Lata, you even
ask Naushad Ji personally about LP & RD, no one but people like you only can comment such
foolish way. As you said, it depends upon your choice, yes it’s true but it could also happen
that you don’t have standar choice at all. Regarding the fact, many people like hardcore
classical only, many people don’t like at all. Some like folk music and some like western
classical It’s not that one is good than the other one is bad, yeah you can do some
comparision between but most of the styles are good and more or less worth listening.
quality wise, in post 69 also you will find golden numbers, even in post 80 you will find many
great songs but ofcourse not quantity wise. So, golden era ranges from 50-80.

No, I am not among them who are fans of Kumar Sanu & Daler Mahendi, I know Sanu’s
voice quality and Daler’s singing style. There is no democracy in music, it’s the change in
taste that can uplift the mediocre ones and there is no relation between democracy and
change in musical tastes. Better try to use proper words next time. You should change yr
taste, try listening to some k.k saigal songs and also A.R. Rahman and Jatin Lalit songs,
I am sure you will find very good compostions from them no matter you can or can’t
compare them with Naushad and SDB or not.

This shows how much mature you are and ho good your taste in music is. I am sure you
know you not judging properly but are you bound to say these for some unavoidable
reasons ?

Contribution ? No, I don’t have. You people are far beyond in this field. You write good
articles and say many facts. Which I don’t but I come to read, but do you think this is an
excuse ? Can this be a reason for writing all those nonsense things ? I couldn’t stop
just reading and I had to do the samething. And again, I didn’t force you to do any kind of
activities. It’s the older members who had been writing and is writing such things, I just
have said againt them which ofcourse people of your group will take as a valid reason and
start doing the same job again. So you are encouraging yourself and doing the things again
and again. I just come st stop your misdeeds, don’t take it as a wrong conception or fight
against you.