Comments on: The Rafi-Kishore saga

By: admin

admin — Fri, 11 Aug 2006 07:15:08 +0000

I don’t see a point in keeping the discussions open for this thread as most what I see here is only bickering! Thanks!

By: unknow1

unknow1 — Fri, 11 Aug 2006 06:32:53 +0000

Dear Avi,
U r wrong?Madan Mohan,SJ,O P Nayar
Naushand said at Zee on Sa re ga ma that Mohd Rafi was 19 and there be 18 and 20 but not 19 I hope u understant what Naushand mean 19?I hope that u listened what Naushand what said about Mohd Rafi, we can give u many big name who said that they are because of Mohd Rafi, Madan Mohan Said that when Mohd Rafi sing he should not be paid please give one name who said about KK,please visit kk site,Sorry to say dear Avi u look like a blind man we are tring to show u but u can’t see because u are blind(sorry for saying that)
Offourse Lata is best female singer and also there are many good female singers but when we speak about male singer there is only Mohd Rafi.

By: avi

avi — Fri, 11 Aug 2006 04:51:01 +0000

Abey Gadhhe Roop,

Saaley talk abt music and defend Rafi. Why u r getting personal?
It shows abt ur bullshit background.

Dear Admin, Pls. go through Roop’s blog, It shows how intelligent rafi fans are !

Boss, first become a good human being.
Let me suggest u one thing. Criticise work but don’t criticise indivisual.

Hope u will take care from ur next blog,

Dear Unknown1,

Kumar sanu sang 21 songs in a day and it is there in guiness book, does it mean he is great…?
Person who knows music and famous personality, (Not like Rafians who claim they know music) never said that Rafi is greatest or Kishore is greatest.
Always they said their fav. are ****.

Naushad never said Rafi was greatest but he said his fav. are Rafi and Mukesh.

But yes, Only one singer in the industry whom everybody accepted as no. 1 is one and only LATA MANGESHKAR.

It is you and me who are saying Rafi is great or Kishore is great.

For your kind informantion, There are many site which talks abt KISHORE, may be more than Rafi. You can find Kishore’s site never argue abt greatest singer and they never have a page like RAFI-KISHORE saga because Kishore’s fans know who is the best. It is one and only KISHORE.

I hope i clear ur doubts abt sites.

By: unknow1

unknow1 — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 20:07:13 +0000

Dear Avi,
I never said that kk is not good,KK was a great or u can say the greatest man in bollywood but when we speak about one man show but when we speak about singer dear AVi no way to compare Mohd Rafi or manny Dey with KK as a SINGER SINGER SINGER i hope u understant,
As u said that Manna Dey accepted that he lost to kishore in â€œPADOSANâ€.Mr Manny dey spoke about this song my time he first didn’t accepted,Yes Maddy dey siad that KK is great maybe it not mean that is greater than Mohd Rafi,If some one say that he is good it not mean that he or she is better than other,
I was looking to SA Re GA MA at Zee Tv there are three who know about music but I can’t understant how one of them give c and other A+.
Dear Avi please visit KK site and write something there because no one write there.
P from LP said it easy to make song for Mohd Rafi,Lata and Asha because how we make it they will sing it but other singer we should make it there style,L from PL said that Mohd Rafi singed six song in one day no other singer can do it.
dear Avi u can’t force any one to like kk because I don’t like kk as singer but it not mean that is bad but as actor i like him so much,
Look dear Avi all in music world they say that mohd Rafi is the best male singer also there are many who said that kk is good singer but no one said that he was better singer than Mohd Raf but there are many who know about music they said about Mohd rafi is the best.

By: Roger

Roger — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 16:25:21 +0000

i have already sokan in length about the ‘ death of originality’ in the present day singers and the fact that Rafi becomes a’ big barrier reef’ in good sence) for the up coming artists.

Now recalling this particular usage of ‘ death of originality’.
You see hindi film singing in particular has evolved from old. Playback singing started with a particular purpose in mind.

GIVING LIFE TO LYRICS can be 1 purpose of play back singing.

This purpose in turn has gotten winded with the with the situation in demand.

By: Anoop Padakandla

Anoop Padakandla — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 16:11:02 +0000

I also appeared under the title Roger and A.V.P in the Mohan flora section (may archive) previously.

By: roop

roop — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 13:30:31 +0000

Let me congratulate the author of the above article for listing the hard facts. Rafi was number 1 from the time he sang Yahan Badla wafa ka in the 40’s till the last time he faced the mic.

Even a simple song like Bhishan Chacha was enough to dislodge several KK numbers, thats a slap on the face of the fustated KK club.

Rafi songs are a very challenging to sing especially those in 40’s, 50’s and 60’s. KK was no where in these decades, he was not even considered a singer. It was only due to the great music of Pancham da and SD Burman that he salvaged something. Even Anu malik would have become popular singer if he was offered hundreds of great tunes to sing.

Rafi was always the first choice for a vast majority of music directors whereas KK was the first choice of the greedy producers (in 70’s only) who wanted to make money of his fame in early 70’s. Music directors never thought much of KK.

Shankar of SJ refused to allow KK to sing Ajab hein dastaan saying that it is not his cup of tea. OP Nayar has said on many ocassions that KK ruined his songs.

However hard these desperate KK club may try they cant change history and its facts. KK does not even come close to Rafi, he is just a mole compared to a mighty mountain of singing, the one and only Rafi.

So go on barking you mad dogs (and jokers)…..

By: roop

roop — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 11:19:12 +0000

Avi

You are a proven gone case, it will be fun playing with a genuine donkey like you. The whole world lost to KK….lol…who lost when Rafi was called to sing songs for him…LOL. KK bechara is a toddler in singing, he is like Aftab Shindasni infront of Sharukh Khan. Bewakuf insaan, see that we do not trace your IP, mooh kala karkar gadhe par baitakar Kandwa ki ser karanoga.

You are a laughing stock and everyone here is literally palying with you. You could win an oscar without any competition for the premium joker of the year, even the best of jokers loose to you.

Stop humiliating KK by your crazy analysis, so who wants to kick his butt first……LOL…lol….LOL

By: avi

avi — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 08:51:41 +0000

Roop,

Don’t force me to use bad words for you.
Boss, I have not said anythign wrong against Rafi.
As this page is on RAFI-KISHORE so i am putting my points.

Boss, If you can’t accept the truth then pls. get out of this site.
Kishore is/was greatest among all. It has been proven.
KK was kid that’s why Manna Dey accepted that he lost to kishore in “PADOSAN”.

I appreciate ur knowledge. Keep it up.

By: roop

roop — Thu, 10 Aug 2006 05:47:30 +0000

Avi

Are you on drugs or are you simply a nut case. You are a perfect example of a sick wacko who is getting needless attention. The modertors of this forum must stop allowing this nonsense.

KK is a kid in singing compared with Mana Dey and Mukesh and a toddler compared with the mighty Rafi.

Get this into your garbage head and buzz off before we find you out.